HMRC & TAX COMPLIANCE

What Happens When HMRC Opens a Tax Enquiry?

Receiving a letter from HMRC can be unsettling, particularly if you are unsure why your tax affairs are being reviewed or what may happen next. Understanding the purpose of an enquiry and getting appropriate support at an early stage can help bring greater clarity to the process.

HMRC & Tax Compliance Updated October 2026

What is an HMRC tax enquiry?

HMRC carries out compliance checks to establish whether the correct amount of tax has been paid and whether tax returns, claims and other information are accurate.

An enquiry or compliance check can relate to an individual taxpayer, a business or a company. The scope of the review will depend on the circumstances and the areas HMRC has chosen to examine.

Being contacted by HMRC does not, by itself, determine the outcome of the enquiry. The purpose of the process is to review the relevant information and establish the correct tax position.

What might HMRC review?

The nature of an HMRC enquiry can vary considerably. Some checks may focus on a particular item, while others may involve a wider review of an individual’s or business’s tax affairs.

01

Tax Returns

This may include Self Assessment or Company Tax Returns and the information reported within them.

02

Accounts & Calculations

HMRC may review accounts, supporting calculations and the figures used to arrive at a tax position.

03

Business Records

Depending on the circumstances, records relating to business income, expenditure or other transactions may be relevant.

04

PAYE & Employment

For employers, a check may include PAYE records, returns and related employment tax matters.

What happens when HMRC makes contact?

HMRC will generally explain what it wishes to check and may ask for information or documents relevant to the enquiry.

Depending on the type and scope of the review, there may be ongoing correspondence while HMRC seeks to understand the tax position. Meetings or visits can also form part of some compliance checks.

At this stage, it is important to understand precisely what is being reviewed and the nature of the information being requested before the matter progresses further.

IMPORTANT

The scope and seriousness of HMRC enquiries can vary significantly. A narrowly focused question and a wider investigation are not the same thing, so understanding the nature of the enquiry is an important early step.

Why responding carefully matters

Correspondence during an HMRC enquiry can influence how efficiently the matter progresses and whether further questions arise.

Information provided to HMRC should accurately reflect the facts and the wider circumstances. Where tax affairs are more complex, an apparently straightforward question may have implications beyond the particular figure or transaction being considered.

This is one reason professional advice can be valuable before substantive responses are made, particularly where there is uncertainty about the underlying tax treatment.

When an enquiry can become more complex

Some HMRC enquiries involve relatively contained issues. Others can become more involved, particularly where there are several sources of income, historic matters or areas where the tax treatment is not straightforward.

01

Undeclared or previously omitted income

02

Property and rental income

03

Overseas income or financial interests

04

Business income and expenditure

05

Historic tax matters

06

Questions around reliefs, claims or tax treatment

What can happen at the end of an enquiry?

Once HMRC has completed its review, it will normally communicate the outcome of the check.

In some cases, the original tax position may remain unchanged. In others, the review may identify that additional tax is due or that too much tax has previously been paid.

No adjustment

The review may conclude without a change to the tax position.

Additional tax

HMRC may conclude that further tax and, where applicable, interest is due.

Repayment

A review may identify that too much tax has previously been paid.

Depending on the circumstances, HMRC may also consider whether a penalty is appropriate. Factors can include the reason an inaccuracy arose and the circumstances surrounding the taxpayer’s conduct.

Does an HMRC enquiry always lead to penalties?

No. The fact that HMRC has opened an enquiry does not automatically mean a penalty will be charged.

Where HMRC identifies an inaccuracy or other compliance issue, the potential consequences will depend on what has happened and the circumstances surrounding it.

HMRC may consider matters such as why an error arose, whether relevant information was disclosed and the level of cooperation during the enquiry.

What if you disagree with HMRC?

There are circumstances in which an HMRC decision, assessment or penalty can be challenged.

However, the appropriate route will depend on the nature of the decision and the tax involved. There may also be formal time limits that apply.

Where there is disagreement over HMRC’s interpretation or proposed outcome, taking advice can help establish the available options and the wider implications of the dispute.

Why getting advice early can help

It can be tempting to regard an initial HMRC letter as something that can be dealt with quickly before seeking professional advice.

However, an early review of the circumstances can help identify the scope of the enquiry, whether there are wider issues that need to be considered and how the matter should be approached.

This can be particularly important where the enquiry concerns historic matters, substantial amounts, several tax years or financial affairs that are more complex.

When professional support may be particularly valuable

Professional advice may be helpful where you have received an HMRC enquiry or compliance check and are uncertain about the issues being raised, the information being requested or the potential tax implications.

It can also be valuable where the matter involves undeclared income, previous tax years, property, overseas interests, business affairs or other circumstances where the position requires careful review.

HOW AMANOR CAN HELP

Have you received an enquiry or letter from HMRC?

Amanor supports individuals and businesses dealing with HMRC enquiries, investigations, disclosures and historic tax matters. We can review your circumstances, help you understand the issues being raised and provide support throughout the process.

Important information

This article is intended for general information only and does not constitute tax or professional advice. HMRC enquiries and tax matters vary depending on the circumstances involved. Advice should be obtained based on your own position before taking or refraining from action.